Chapter One – Purpose in Creation or Purpose in Redemption
This chapter is marketed as “everything starts with God.” But in reality, it is all about the image of man as related to the original creation. The problem with this is that being born into this world does not equate to being born “by his purpose and for his purpose” (p.17) in a necessarily good sense. If we were not fallen creatures in Adam, we might agree with Warren when he states in a positive manner “You were born by his purpose and for his purpose.” But the reality is that we are born “in Adam” a sinful creature rebellious to God.
Warren quotes Colossians 1:16 to introduce his first chapter. This quote is specific to the Person of the Lord Jesus Christ. It is the preeminence of Jesus Christ as Lord over all of His creation. Warren does not include the full text which also says that he created all things “whether thrones or dominions or rulers or authorities.” Why is this significant? It is this: Jesus Christ is Lord over everything that has been created, whether it is in rebellion to Him or not! He reigns over it! We must not prematurely take assurance or comfort in the fact that He has made everything for His purpose because even the devil and hell itself fulfills a specific purpose of God.
Next, we must ask, if this chapter really is all about God, why does Warren misquote and misapply texts of Scripture that enhance man’s image in his fallen state? The following three points in chapter 1 confirm this:
-
- Warren says (p.18) “Many people try to use God for their own self-actualization…” He then denies that is what his book is about. Then continuing with his thought two paragraphs later on the very next page he quotes from The Message Bible: “Self-help is no help at all. Self-sacrifice is the way, my way, to finding yourself, your true self.”
The same Scripture in the NASB says: “For whoever wishes to save his life shall lose it; but whoever loses his life for My sake shall find it.”
The same Scripture in the KJV Bible says: “For whosoever will save his life shall lose it; but whosoever will lose his life for My sake shall find it.”
The Message Bible misquotes Holy Scripture! The context of the passage in question is of course the verse before: Matthew 16:24 “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.” (KJV)
Ponder for a moment the mistranslation “self-sacrifice is…my way” versus the true meaning “whoever loses his life for My sake.” This is not about self “doing” through “self-sacrifice” so “self” can attain a “self” identity. In context, it is about self “dying,” and it is about the new object found, which is Jesus Christ Himself, and not that which is supposedly the “true” self. This is the death of self to Christ. It is conversion, not self-actualization through self-sacrifice. It is about a new identity, but only as it relates to Jesus Christ and for His sake.
Even though he says his book is not about self-actualization, Warren uses a mistranslation of Scripture to make this text seem like it is about self-actualization – which it is not. The Message Bible quote is obviously a very poor paraphrase of the Holy Scriptures which is then used by Warren to support his point.
-
- Warren claims (p. 20) that we can have “God’s wisdom” from the Word of God. He then quotes about God’s wisdom from 1Corinthians 2:7. Yet, on the next page in describing this “wisdom” he tells a story of someone who had an “experience” of deity. (p.21) “Suddenly, all by itself, a phrase appeared: Without God life makes no sense. Repeating it in astonishment, I rode the phrase up like a moving staircase, got out of the metro and walked into God’s light.” (He then summarizes your purpose for life (via his book) as though you are walking into the light.) That statement should be found in a book on New Age Mysticism so that you couldn’t miss what it really is! How disconcerting that you find it in this “Christian” book. The good thing is that it doesn’t matter what it is labeled. It only matters if it is truth.
God’s wisdom that Paul describes in 1 Corinthians 1:17-2:2 is the real wisdom of the cross! Warren uses this very passage to support his own version of wisdom! Jesus had to be crucified because we are sinners! This is the only way we can be saved. The wisdom of the cross is that God can still be a holy God and yet can save sinners in the foolishness of the gospel preached. This wisdom is not that we can decide through some mystical experience that we need God and we secure the knowledge of God by our walk into the “light.” Salvation is of God and is based in the message of Christ crucified for sinners. Thus, Warren’s example leads us astray from Scripture.
-
- Warren’s own interpretation of 1 Corinthians 2:7 leads us astray as well.
Here is his quote from the Message Bible: “God’s wisdom…goes deep into the interior of his purposes…It’s not the latest message, but more like the oldest – what God determined as the way to bring out his best in us.”
Now let’s read the same passage from the New American Standard Version: “But we speak God’s wisdom in a mystery, the hidden wisdom, which God predestined before the ages to our glory;”
Now we read from the King James Version: “But we speak the wisdom of God in a mystery, even the hidden wisdom, which God ordained before the world unto our glory:”
As you can see, the Message Bible is misquoting the Holy Word of God once again! God’s wisdom is the reality of His being able to save us through the gospel as Paul had already made clear in 1 Corinthians 1:17-2:2. That is what is to “our glory.” It was determined this way from eternity, and it is His wisdom, Christ crucified for sinners! In our conversion, He makes us new creatures in Christ Jesus with a new life from and in Him. This wisdom is not “God bringing out his best in us.” In fact, the Scriptures say that our “old man” (sinful nature) was crucified at Calvary when we were placed “in Christ.” (Galatians 2:20; Romans 6:6) God did not “bring out his best in us” in crucifying Christ. In Christ Jesus, He forgave us all of our sins, identifying us with His crucified Son on Calvary, and recreating us anew, giving us a new heart!
Unfortunately, Warren introduces you to a different wisdom and labels it God’s wisdom. You might not have even noticed since you were reading a “Christian” book. Instead of your thoughts entering the door of “Christ Jesus crucified” they were taken through the door of “mysticism/humanistic philosophy.” The reality is that the “wisdom” throughout this book is consistent with the example and the Scriptural mis-quote cited above. It has nothing to do with the wisdom which Paul describes in 1 Corinthians.
Thus, Warren begins his book by laying a humanistic philosophy based in the original creation as if the fall was inconsequential to you. At the same time, he is negating and twisting Scripture which clearly describes to us the need and provision in Christ of His life and a new creation via His crucifixion, resurrection, and our death and new life in Him.